Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Viewer Mail 4: Where Should I Live?

This question comes from a young jazz guitar student from British Columbia. Actually, this question was asked on Facebook, but I thought it would go well as part of the blog:


Hey George, I am going to graduate with a B.mus. in Jazz next summer. Nowhere close to pro chops but working on it. Do you recommend moving to a city with a real scene right away, or bumming around somewhere cheaper while I woodshed a little longer?

- Alexis Deighton Harrison


Dear Alexis:


Interesting question. If you had a ton of money in the bank, or could work during the day as a hedge fund manager, I would say by all means move to New York City. (When you get to Wall Street, you might see a bunch of crazy protesters who hate freedom and so forth. Just ignore them.) But the fact that you used the phrase "bumming around" could imply that you are not independently wealthy. (Although some rich people might say something like, "I'm just going to bum around East Hampton for a year until my inheritance kicks in." Totally different use of the word "bumming.") So moving to New York can be tough, even for somewhat established musicians like myself.(That's why I don't live there anymore. HA!)

The New York Jazz scene is the best in the world in terms of number of musicians per square inch, being able to hear the best known and unknown players every night of the week, and getting your ass beaten musically(which could make you a better player...). I lived in New York from 1995 to 2009, and I believe that I would not have developed in the same way if I had stayed in D.C. or Baltimore. However, I DID wait for 4 years after I graduated college. I waited until I felt I was ready to move to New York. I could have moved sooner, but I also started late playing jazz piano, so I needed the time to play catch up. And I was also playing with some name cats when I moved there, so I had a bit of an in. Furthermore, New York was VERY DIFFERENT in the 90's. There was much more work in the city, and much more touring work. 

That all changed after 9/11. I found it impossible to make a living in the city, and I think that's still the case, unless you do Broadway shows, have a job with the Symphony, or teach 40 students a week(or have a full time teaching position, which is slim pickins in New York City.) Even in the 90's, most of my bread came from tours, and as I got older and touring became less and less fun, I was stuck between not touring and going broke, or touring all the time and being miserable, or not working in town AND not touring and REALLY going broke, or ....TA DA! Find a teaching job. So I pursued that for many years, first ending up in Winnipeg, and then being in Portland now.

I realize I'm going off on a tangent. Older people tend to do that.

Now it's interesting, I think, because I feel like there ARE scenes outside of New York, that should be cultivated, not only for their own sake, but just because New York doesn't need any more musicians moving there. I believe that the "Either you are in New York or you not, and New York is where it's at" philosophy has not always been universal, and that New York is actually becoming less and less relevant. For example, I know some very successful musicians in Europe who have only visited New York a handful of times. And when you start to look around, you notice how many musicians DON'T live in New York and never did.

OK, so what does ANY of that claptrap have to do with you? Well, I think unfortunately, you answered your own question at the beginning. And I don't really know your playing either, so if you could prove to me that you were the next Kurt Rosenwinkel, then maybe I would say run, don't walk, to New York. (BTW, Kurt doesn't even live in New York.He got a teaching gig in Berlin. HA!) But I'm guessing that being on a smaller scene would most likely benefit you more than being lost in the shuffle in New York.

I would try to sell you on doing your Master's at PSU( I'm supposed to be recruiting, after all...). Portland has, from what I can tell so far, a good scene. It's cheaper to live here than most of the other cities that you might have considered(Vancouver, Toronto, maybe even Montreal. And it's not as cold!).

I'm guessing that what you need to do is PLAY! And if you can find a place where you get to play on a regular basis, and not have to worry about rent and health insurance and all that, then go there. I played tons of gigs in Baltimore and Washington D.C., and that's really how I got my stuff together. I think If I had moved to New York right away, I might have been overwhelmed.

Maybe I would have quit.

You might also want to live somewhere cheap so that you can save your money and make regular "fact finding" excursions to New York. Spend a week every 3 to 6 months in New York. Take some lessons, go to gigs, try to meet some players.

What about a Canada Council Grant? In the 90's, it seemed like every other day I would run in to somebody who was living in New York on a Canada Council Grant.

But I would say smaller is better for now. Also, you might consider Europe. I hear great things about Berlin. It's cheap to live there and it's a great vibe. Not sure about the jazz scene. It all depends on who you talk to.

Anyway, good luck, and I hope the ramblings of a jaded jazz edumacator helped you. And feel free to ask any more questions.          

68 comments:

  1. The Arab League's plan has been the focus of efforts to find a diplomatic solution and comes as key international players such as Russia and the US warned of the danger of civil war in Syria.
    Passages Malibugalway self catering
    Syria was reported to have agreed in principle to accept the Arab League's peace plan but critics accused it of stalling for time.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Even in the 90's, most of my bread came from tours, and as I got older and touring became less and less fun, I was stuck between not touring and going broke, or touring all the time and being miserable, or not working in town AND not touring and REALLY going broke...
    best vacuum for pet hairsouthern maryland real estate

    ReplyDelete
  3. I know some very successful musicians in Europe who have only visited New York a handful of times. And when you start to look around, you notice how many musicians DON'T live in New York and never did.
    janitor supplies louisvilleaftermarket auto parts

    ReplyDelete
  4. I know some very successful musicians in Europe who have only visited New York a handful of times gratis partner sucheDécoration soirée

    ReplyDelete
  5. Amphiphiles are oily compounds containing a hydrophilic head on one or both ends of a hydrophobic molecule. fire insurance claimsMarine Phytoplankton

    ReplyDelete
  6. charm jewelersseriöse partnersuche

    i carry your heart with me(i carry it in
    my heart)i am never without it(anywhere
    i go you go,my dear; and whatever is done
    by only me is your doing,my darling)
    i fear
    no fate(for you are my fate,my sweet)i want
    no world(for beautiful you are my world,my true)
    and it's you are whatever a moon has always meant
    and whatever a sun will always sing is you

    ReplyDelete
  7. bling bling jewelryBottle Opener

    For off, when on my couch I lie
    In vacant or in pensive mood,
    They flash upon that inward eye
    Which is the bliss of solitude :
    And then my heart with pleasure fills,
    And dance with the daffodils.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Even in the 90's, most of my bread came from tours, and as I got older and touring became less and less fun, I was stuck between not touring and going broke, or touring all the time and being miserable, or not working in town AND not touring and REALLY going broke...china wholesaleDebt Settlement Companies

    ReplyDelete
  9. Even in the 90's, most of my bread came from tours, and as I got older and touring became less and less fun, I was stuck between not touring and going broke, or touring all the time and being miserable, or not working in town AND not touring and REALLY going broke...Interior Designers MiamiIT Support services

    ReplyDelete
  10. In South Vietnam itself, the raids stoked widespread anger. Several high-ranking public servants resigned, and university and high school students boycotted classes and staged riotous demonstrations, resulting in further mass incarcerations.
    Movers Sacramento CAcredit cards

    ReplyDelete
  11. Apartamentos de vacaciones en Madeiraopt in leads

    Why, teacher, why.. why.. why ?
    I have no dad nor a sister left.
    To teach me and to care for me you said, was that a lie ?
    This time with tearful eyes she, again, said...
    "Be a grown one, young man,
    Can't you see we all are dying ?
    And stop this with your might as soon as you can,
    For we all are suffering."

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hotels near Oprylandroof insulation
    Great to see you at the con as well! Hey, maybe we'll have tables next to one another next year!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Wedding Photography and Bridal Make-UpCatering Atlanta
    Crime scene clean-up businesses are a growing industry in the United States. These firms provide a valuable service to bereaved or victimized families by cleaning up the aftermath of a violent death or injury and returning the property to its original condition

    ReplyDelete
  14. printer cartridge inkbox trailers brisbane


    My soul awoke with decision:
    And you again came as a blest,
    Like an enchanting fleeting vision,
    A spirit of the pure grace.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Database Programmingweb designDescription: This week, singer John Legend repeated his aim to donate his Bush Tax Cut millionaire's windfall to help offset cuts in the arts, and help Americans hurt despite signs of economic recovery. Contrast this with this week s other news: former Massachusetts governor and possible 2012 presidential aspirant Mitt Romney penned an op-ed in The Boston Herald purporting to offer a blueprint for "more jobs."Of course, Mitt Romney didn t say "more jobs for African Americans"--who ve seen...

    ReplyDelete
  16. Why, teacher, why.. why.. why ?
    I have no dad nor a sister left.
    To teach me and to care for me you said, was that a lie ?
    This time with tearful eyes she, again, said...
    "Be a grown one, young man,
    Can't you see we all are dying ?
    And stop this with your might as soon as you can,
    For we all are suffering."Toronto Homes For Saletucson long realty

    ReplyDelete
  17. Wedding Photography and Bridal Make-UpCatering Atlanta
    Crime scene clean-up businesses are a growing industry in the United States. These firms provide a valuable service to bereaved or victimized families by cleaning up the aftermath of a violent death or injury and returning the property to its original conditionText übersetzen Deutsch FranzösischPine needle oil

    ReplyDelete
  18. The protocol, initially adopted in Kyoto, Japan, in 1997, is aimed at fighting global warming. Through the agreement, countries like China and India take voluntary, but non-binding steps to reduce their carbon emissions.

    Japan's own environment minister, Goshi Hosono, urged Canada to stay in the protocol.
    anti aging natural supplementsorganic supplements

    ReplyDelete
  19. Without the allure of capturing the pole, he would struggle to maintain public interest or funding. "If the expedition was to be saved ... there was nothing left for me but to try and solve the last great problem—the South Pole".
    Yowah Opals Queen of Gemsbillig sexlegetøj

    ReplyDelete
  20. Hervey Bay Accommodationmusicona

    I wandered lonely as a cloud
    That floats on high o' er vales and Hills.
    When all at once I saw a crowd,
    A host of goden daffodils:

    ReplyDelete
  21. e-burstκατασκευή ιστοσελίδων
    Yes we'll walk with a walk that is measured and slow,And we'll go where the chalk-white arrows go,For the children, they mark, and the children, they knowThe place where the sidewalk ends. 

    ReplyDelete
  22. garden sheds liverpoolantigua holiday
    Freighted with hope, Crimsoned with joy, We scatter the leaves of our opening rose; Their widening scope, Their distant employ, We never shall know. And the stream as it flows Sweeps them away, Each one is gone Ever beyond into infinite ways. We alone stay While years hurry on, The flower fared forth, though its fragrance still stays.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Music for PowerPoint presentationshotels in edinburghBeside the lake, beneath the trees, Fluttering and dancing in the breeze. Continuous as the stars that shine And twinkle on the Milky Way, They stretched in a never-ending line Along thousand saw I at a glance, Tossing thier in sprightly dance. 

    ReplyDelete
  24. solid shedsGumtree


    Is he alive? And his sweet lady?
    And where is now their little nook?
    Or maybe they had both faded,
    Like this strange flower in this book?

    ReplyDelete
  25. raspberry ketonecopycat recipes
    Promisingly, this now means that over half of British Land's commercial developments in London have been pre-let before completion showing that their ambitious progression of their development pipeline despite an insipidly performing British economy, a decision some have seen as excessively risky, has been the right choice.

    ReplyDelete
  26. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  27. used ophthalmic equipmentFast Laptop Repair
    SCPA students are encouraged to compete in arts competitions at all levels, including international contests like the World Piano Competition and the American High School Theater Festival in Edinburgh.[125] Honors since 2008 have included first place in the Ohioana Robert Fox Award for Young Writers, a bronze medal at the Cincinnati World Piano Competition, top honors at the Days of International Choir Music Competition, and the 2008 Cincinnati Arts Association Overture Award in Visual Art.

    ReplyDelete
  28. banner standDrug RehabIn the hands of these criminals your hard drive could be worth a fortune and may very well lose you a fortune. Remember they could have possession of all your bank account numbers, user names and passwords

    ReplyDelete
  29. gold coast real estate agentsfree ads
    On July 1, 2004, the Cassini–Huygens space probe performed the SOI (Saturn Orbit Insertion) maneuver and entered into orbit around Saturn. Before the SOI, Cassini had already studied the system extensively

    ReplyDelete
  30. I know some very successful musicians in Europe who have only visited New York a handful of times grati
    Aduitor for file systemfree cpanel hosting

    ReplyDelete
  31. Few good locksmiths work at night and on weekends, so we are in great demand by customers, offering them quality locksmith services whenever you need them. ключар

    ReplyDelete
  32. Before contacting us for assistance, we encourage you to try some of these simple methods to drain, sinks and drains, which will save you rahodi but to us your legwork. отпушване на канали

    ReplyDelete
  33. With the Single European Act (1986) in the text of the EEC Treaty included a new Article 102a, which specifies cooperation as a condition for convergence of economic and monetary policies of member countries. Димитър Веселинов Калинов

    ReplyDelete
  34. Rechtsanwalt Kreuztalindustrial flangesIt strengthened to become a tropical cyclone before striking northwestern Madagascar on January 28. Elita weakened to tropical depression status while crossing the island, and after exiting into the southwest Indian Ocean it turned to the west and moved ashore for a second time on January 31 in eastern Madagascar.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Section XVIII art. 163-173 (XV 130f-p) of the Treaty, "Research and technological development", with the aim to strengthen the scientific and technological bases of Community industry and to encourage to become more competitive at international level, developing all research in other areas deemed necessary.
    електротехник

    ReplyDelete
  36. Coursework writingcharm braceletsThe city's growth began in the mid-1980s, when Toyota built Toyota Motor Manufacturing Kentucky, the first wholly owned United States plant, in a recently[when?] annexed part of the city. The plant, which currently builds the Camry, Camry Hybrid, Venza, and Avalon automobiles, opened in 1988. It is the largest building in terms of acres covered under one building in the United States, with over 200 acres (0.8 km2) occupied. The city also serves as the home of the annual training camp for the NFL's Cincinnati Bengals.

    ReplyDelete
  37.  steps will be taken on the approximation of VAT rates and other indirect taxes. Some are minimum rates and excise duties. електро услуги

    ReplyDelete
  38. However, some states in which the predominant number of women - such as Kerala (1036 females per 1000 males). дърводелски услуги

    ReplyDelete
  39. Moreover, advanced synthesis of specialty chemicals that enhance the quality of industrial production. смяна на щрангове

    ReplyDelete
  40. To become a member of Parliament must be a citizen of India and therefore over 30 years in the case of Raja Sabha and 25 in the case of the Lok Sabha. вик ремонти

    ReplyDelete
  41. send cookiesVoucherCodesNet79 of the fatalities were aged 30 or younger. Two sisters and three pairs of brothers, and a father and son were among the fatalities.[15] Also among the dead were two men who were about to become fathers for the first time; 25-year-old Steven Brown of Wrexham[20] and 30-year-old Peter Thompson of Widnes.

    ReplyDelete
  42. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  43. To the north and east borders of Assam and to the south and west by Bangladesh. The state is mainly inhabited by tribes pastes, Garo and rim. бойлери

    ReplyDelete
  44. Weightwatchers Voucher Codesmarriage affairsEnvironmental degradation is the deterioration of the environment through depletion of resources such as air, water and soil; the destruction of ecosystems and the extinction of wildlife. It is defined as any change or disturbance to the environment perceived to be deleterious or undesirable.

    ReplyDelete
  45. business development3d folie Among the early protectionists that stood out as leaders in the movement were Henry David Thoreau, John Muir and George Perkins Marsh. Thoreau was concerned about the wildlife in Massachusetts; he wrote Walden; or, Life in the Woods as he studied the wildlife from a cabin. John Muir founded the Sierra Club, one of the largest conservation organizations in the United States. Marsh was influential with regards to the need for resource conservation.

    ReplyDelete
  46. keratin hair treatment

    Interior Decorator Miami As Eloise progressed westward, it affected Cuba, though to a lesser extent. Upon making landfall in Florida, Eloise generated winds reportedly gusting to 155 mph (249 km/h). Hundreds of buildings were demolished by the powerful winds and strong storm surge.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Air Fuji marks are extremely common air conditioners due to their excellent quality and reasonable price. мобилни климатици

    ReplyDelete
  48. discount louis vuitton bags
    lean cuisine rewardsMost boys like to think they have a girl friend, especially the 13 to 14 year olds. I would like to see an article on how to get a girl, and when you've got her, how to keep and please her. I would also like to see more articles on music in B.O.P. as I am a trombonist in the Tiffin School Band.

    ReplyDelete
  49. Proactol Plus Reviews
    replicas de relogios CartierElevation differences range from 75 metres (246 ft) above-sea-level at the Lake Ontario shore to 209 m (686 ft) ASL near the York University grounds in the city's north end at the intersection of Keele Street and Steeles Avenue.[36] There are occasional hilly areas, in particular midtown Toronto has a number of rolling hills, some of which are of considerable height. Lake Ontario remains occasionally visible from the peaks of these ridges as far north as Eglinton Avenue, 7 to 8 kilometres (4.3 to 5.0 mi) inland.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Clearances may have been to accommodate sheep or game estates, or enclosure, or may have resulted from depopulation, such as after the Black Death or following a move of the inhabitants to more prosperous districts. Other villages have grown and merged and often form hubs within the general mass of suburbia — such as Hampstead, London and Didsbury in Manchester. Many villages are now predominantly dormitory locations and have suffered the loss of shops, churches and other facilities.
    dental implants dublin

    cabelos

    ReplyDelete
  51. An independent association named Les Plus Beaux Villages de France, was created in 1982 to promote assets of small and picturesque French villages of quality heritage. As of 2008, 152 villages in France have been listed in "The Most Beautiful Villages of France".
    estetica y belleza las rozas

    electronic cigarettes Australia

    ReplyDelete
  52. Russian-language schooling is also available in Latvia, Estonia and Lithuania. However, due to recent high school reforms in Latvia (whereby the government pays a substantial sum to a school to teach in the national language), the number of subjects taught in Russian has been reduced in the country.
    Heavy Metals Test

    contactos

    ReplyDelete
  53. In other interpretations, the Cephalotaxaceae may be better included within the Taxaceae, and some authors additionally recognize Phyllocladaceae as distinct from Podocarpaceae (in which it is included here).
    Ionised Water

    slut book

    ReplyDelete
  54. In the third stage is implemented feedback evaluations. He received the results
    klimatistika of assessment

    ReplyDelete
  55. The system changed slightly at the end of 1990s, when population growth became very low. In many cases, where capital punishment was de facto,[citation needed] it was replaced by less severe punishments.
    MLS.ca

    finger food catering brisbane

    ReplyDelete
  56. The following day, the Supreme Soviet, the highest governmental body of the Soviet Union, dissolved itself. This is generally recognized as marking the official, final dissolution of the Soviet Union as a functioning state. Many organizations, such as the Soviet Army and police forces, remained in place in the early months of 1992, but were slowly phased out and either withdrawn from or absorbed by the newly independent states.
    Kochi

    first date advice

    ReplyDelete
  57. Allocated resources and plan targets were normally denominated in rubles rather than in physical goods. Credit was discouraged, but widespread. Final allocation of output was achieved through relatively decentralized, unplanned contracting. Although in theory prices were legally set from above, in practice the actual prices were often negotiated, and informal horizontal links (between producer factories etc.) were widespread.
    dentist dublin

    top free dating sites

    ReplyDelete
  58. David Wilson, a historian, believed that the gas industry would account for 40 percent of Soviet fuel production by the end of the century. His theory did not come to fruition because of the USSR's collapse.[81] The USSR, in theory, would have continued to have an economic growth rate of 2–2.5 percent during the 1990s because of Soviet energy fields[clarification needed].
    text online

    dating

    ReplyDelete
  59. The Soviet Union placed great emphasis on science and technology within its economy,[87] however, the most remarkable Soviet successes in technology, such as producing the world's first space satellite, typically were the responsibility of the military.[70] Lenin believed that the USSR would never overtake the developed world if it remained as technologically backward as it was.
    Acne Scar Removal

    Pressure washer repair

    ReplyDelete
  60. Between 4500 and 3000 BC, these central European neolithic cultures developed further to the west and the north, transmitting newly acquired skills in producing copper artefacts. In Western Europe the Neolithic period was characterized not by large agricultural settlements but by field monuments, such as causewayed enclosures, burial mounds and megalithic tombs.[33] The Corded Ware cultural horizon flourished at the transition from the Neolithic to the Chalcolithic.
    Gumtree Jobs

    chauffeur service sydney

    ReplyDelete
  61. At the start of the Battle of Gallipoli the AIF had four infantry brigades with the first three making up the 1st Division. The 4th Brigade was joined with the sole New Zealand infantry brigade to form the New Zealand and Australian Division. The 2nd Division had been formed in Egypt in 1915 and was sent to Gallipoli in August. After Gallipoli, the infantry underwent a major expansion. The 3rd Division was formed in Australia and sent to France.
    Madeira self catering

    colorful glasses frames

    ReplyDelete
  62. The French began their occupation of Algiers in 1830, starting with a landing in Algiers. As occupation turned into colonization, Kabylia remained the only region independent of the French government. Pressure on the region increased, and the will of her people to resist and defend Kabylie increased as well.
    stone animal statues

    free dating search engine

    ReplyDelete
  63. Today there are many cognate words across the different islands e.g. tapu, ali'i, motu, kava (Kava culture), and tapa as well as Hawaiki, the mythical homeland for some of the cultures.
    Extended Auto Warranty

    ultramarine blue pigment

    ReplyDelete
  64. At ultraviolet and visible wavelengths, Uranus's atmosphere is remarkably bland in comparison to the other gas giants, even to Neptune, which it otherwise closely resembles.[18] When Voyager 2 flew by Uranus in 1986, it observed a total of ten cloud features across the entire planet.[17][95] One proposed explanation for this dearth of features is that Uranus's internal heat appears markedly lower than that of the other giant planets. The lowest temperature recorded in Uranus's tropopause is 49 K, making Uranus the coldest planet in the Solar System, colder than Neptune.
    Mexico Real Estate

    mind maps

    ReplyDelete
  65. Her idea is to offer quality as the originals, but at a климатици Fujitsu lower price.

    ReplyDelete
  66. Moreover, cultural differences are difficult to overcome. ключарски услуги

    ReplyDelete
  67. Real quality cartridge may have a форум за климатици higher price than that of the lock. вентилация

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.